Menu Close

How was Jonas reprimanded?

How was Jonas reprimanded?

Jonas was once publicly chastised because he took an apple home from the Recreation Area. The Speaker didn’t mention Jonas’ name over the loudspeaker, but both Jonas and his parents knew that the reprimand was directed at him. He broke a rule, and the next day he promptly apologized to the Recreation Director.

What happened to Jonas after he took the apple?

Suddenly, Jonas noticed a change in the apple while it was in mid-air. However, the apple changed back to normal when he caught it. As Jonas continued to play catch with the apple, it would continue to mysteriously change in mid-air.

Why does Jonas take the apple?

Jonas had taken the apple because, while playing catch with his friend Asher, he had noticed the apple change in a way he could not describe. On closer investigation, the apple remained the same shape, size, and nondescript shade as always, but then it would briefly change again, though Asher did not seem to notice.

What page does Jonas see the Apple change color?

Jonas sees the apple change color in mid-air and perceives its red appearance for the first time. In chapter 3, Jonas recalls a time when he casually took an apple out a basket in the recreation area and threw it to his friend, Asher.

Who has red hair in the giver?


Hair Red
Appearances The Giver
Mentioned Messenger (indirectly)
Portrayed by Odeya Rush

What realization struck Jonas in the giver?

The realization that struck Jonas about the last rule is that all twelves may have been given the same rule. Even though he could ask whatever question he wanted, he couldn’t be sure if they were telling the truth. Jonas was surprised by all the books in the Receiver’s house.

What is frustrating about changing the rules in the giver?

Sometimes it takes so long that everyone forgets that a change had even been requested. The long, multi-step process is the reason why it takes so long. This stems from the reality of life in the community: the society is closely controlled and regulated. Rules are intentionally made to maintain this order.

Why must Jonas take pills?

Why must Jonas take pills? According to community rules, Jonas must take a pill to stop “the stirrings,” or the onset of sexual desire during puberty. Jonas’s mother gives him the pills after he talks about an erotic dream in which he wanted to bathe Fiona, which reveals Jonas’s burgeoning sexuality.

Who has red hair in The Giver?

What happened with the apple in The Giver?

When Jonas sees the apple “change” in The Giver, nothing is actually happening to the apple; the change is happening to Jonas. He is beginning to see color for the very first time. Since Jonas has no concept of what color actually is, he only sees it as a change in the object. Jonas is starting to see in color.

What is Jonas’s first lie?

Jonas’ first experience with lying came when he asked his parents about love, after which, he received a stern lecture about the necessity for precision of language. When Jonas’ mother asked him if he understood that using a word like “love” was inappropriate, he lied and told her yes.

Did The Giver ever get married?

Did the giver ever get married? Yes but it was difficult because the giver could not share his memories or books with her. Now his wife lives with the childless adults.