Why did Elie Wiesel lie to his relative Stein?

Why did Elie Wiesel lie to his relative Stein?

The reason Elie initially lied to Stein about the fate of his family was to give him hope and a reason to survive. Elie understands that without hope and something to live for, one can easily give up and die in the horrific environment.

When did Elie lie to Stein?

When Stein heard a transport had come in from Eliezer’s region, he came to Eliezer and his father inquiring if they had corresponded with his family. While Eliezer did not have any knowledge about Stein’s family, he decided to lie, and explained that they had corresponded and the family was doing well.

Why did Elie lie to Stein quizlet?

Elie lied because he wanted Stein to have some hope of them surviving and so the German’s didn’t know about them. He stops seeing them because the German leader who was running it was replaced and he decides to take a transport to see Reizel and his two boys.

What did Elie tell a lie about?

Taking the prisoner’s advice, Eliezer lies about his age, telling Mengele he is eighteen. He also says that he is a farmer rather than a student, and is motioned to Mengele’s left, along with his father. Despite Eliezer’s joy at remaining with his father, uncertainty remains.

What did Stein finally realize?

Stein finally learned the truth about his family. Although Wiesel does not tell the reader exactly what happened, it can be assumed that Stein’s family, like all the others, were either deported to a concentration camp, had died of disease or starvation, or had been killed.

Why did Elie lie to Stein about his wife and daughters condition was he right to lie would you have lied in that situation?

Elie lied because he thought offering his relative hope was a kind thing to do. In one sense, he was right, as Stein lived longer than he would have if he had learned the truth earlier, In another sense, of course, false hope is almost worse than no hope at all. Stein came to the same end in any case.

Did Elie Wiesel lie about his age?

As mentioned above, Elie lies about his age and occupation so that he can stay alive for as long as possible. In the novel, the prisoner advises Elie to say that he is eighteen years old (rather than fifteen) so that he can be considered a viable candidate for work detail.

What is the best explanation for why Elie lied to Stein of Antwerp — remember he told Stein that he had heard good news about his wife and children?

Who is the boy underneath Wiesel?

Who was the boy underneath Elie? It was Juliek, a Polish boy who played the violin.

Why does Eliezer lie and tell the SS that he is a farmer?

Why does Eliezer lie and tell the SS that he is a farmer, instead of admitting he is a student? He wants to work in the fields and not in the school. He wants them to know he shouldn’t be in the camp. He wants them to think he is strong and can do work.

Why did Elie lie to Dr Mengele about his age and occupation?

Mengele asks Ellie about his age and occupation– he said he was a farmer at age 18. He lied so that he and his father could stay together and seemed fit and old enough to work.

Who is Stein in Elie Wiesel Chapter 3?

Log in here. In chapter 3, Elie’s relative named Stein approaches his father on their eighth day at Auschwitz, and Elie’s father does not remember him. However, Elie mentions that he recognizes Stein immediately and listens to Stein ask whether they received any news about his wife, Reizel, and his two small boys.

Why did Stein never come back to see the Weisels?

One day a new transport arrives from Antwerp. Stein is full of hope when he goes to see if he can find his wife and children. Stein never comes back to see the Weisels because, Elie says, he discovers the truth. The implication is that, once he discovered that his family had been killed, Stein simply faded out of existence.

Why did Elie lie to his father about Stein?

While he knows that Stein will never see his family again, he also knows that there can be no benefit from divulging this information. By lying, and allowing Stein to keep his hope alive, Elie does the kindest thing possible in the circumstances. On their eighth day in Auschwitz, Elie and his father are visited by their relative Stein from Antwerp.

Why did Stein come to look for Reizel?

Stein mentions that he heard a transport arrived from their region and came to look for the Wiesels, hoping they might have some news about Reizel and his two boys. Stein then comments that the only thing keeping him alive is the thought that Reizel and his two little ones are doing alright.