What might the incident involving Asher asking for a smack instead of a snack indicate about the community what kind of people are they?

What might the incident involving Asher asking for a smack instead of a snack indicate about the community what kind of people are they?

It shows that they are really into discipline. It shows they are very regimented — they always use the same punishment and it is always called the same thing. It shows that they care very deeply about being sure that people use the correct words.

What did Asher do in the giver?

Asher was assigned the job of Assistant Recreational Director in the book, and assigned Pilot in the movie. (He was the fourth one to receive his job assignment as his birth number is #4, meaning that he was the fourth child born in his year out of 50 children.

When did Asher say smack instead of snack he was punished with?

The Chief Elder recalls Asher’s struggles as a child with language acquisition and how difficult it was for him to tell the difference between the words “snack” and “smack.” Every time Asher would mistake the words “snack” and “smack,” a Childcare specialist would strike him with a “discipline wand.” Asher continued to …

What was the main reason why the discipline wand was used on Asher?

The community uses something called a Discipline Wand to smack children as a reprimand for misbehavior. As a three year old, little Asher really wanted his snack, but said “smack” instead. At this point, “Asher whimpered, cringed, and corrected himself instantly” in a whisper.

How was Asher disciplined for using the incorrect word for snack?

She recalls a time when Asher confused the words “snack” and “smack” at the Childcare Center, and received a smack with the discipline wand every time.

What was Asher’s assignment *?

the Assistant Director of Recreation
In the book, Asher (Cameron Monaghan) is assigned to be the Assistant Director of Recreation.

What negative effect did the discipline wand have on Asher?

He couldn’t seem to stop, though for each lapse the discipline wand came again, escalating to a series of painful lashes that left marks on Asher’s legs. Eventually, for a period of time, Asher stopped talking altogether, when he was a Three.

What did Asher’s hesitation in congratulating?

Jonas interpreted that Asher’s hesitation in congratulating him as uncertainty and he didn’t know what Jonas would have to do or why he was selected. Also, he was scared to think that everyone was allowed to lie and he would never have a way of knowing if the answers he received were true.

Why did Asher mix up the words snack and Smack?

When Asher and Jonas were Threes, Asher mixed up the words “snack” and “smack” one day as he was standing in line for his morning snack. The Childcare worker immediately gave him what he said he wanted: a smack.

Why was Asher punished in the Giver book?

In The Giver, Asher was punished as a child for confusing the words “snack” and “smack” because the community values precise language. Citizens are required to use precise language at all times, and even exaggerations are prohibited.

Why did Asher get smacked with a wand?

First of all, we learn that kids are smacked with a wand when they mess up. Hopefully that’s not like your school! So we learn that in this society it is very common for children to receive corporal punishment. But the story even goes a step further! Little Asher would get smacked for messing up the word.

Why did Asher keep getting disciplined when he was three?

Why did Asher keep getting disciplined when he was a three? As a toddler, Asher “always talked too fast and mixed up words” while he was trying to master precision of language (ch 7, p. 55).