What is Socrates argument against Meletus?

What is Socrates argument against Meletus?

Socrates replies to Meletus that, in doing harm to others and hurting all of society, Socrates would thus also be hurting himself, as a member of society. Socrates claims that he cannot possibly be so foolish as to want to hurt himself, and so if he does cause harm, it must be unintentional.

What does Socrates discuss with Meletus?

Concerning the accusation that Socrates believed in strange spirits and not the gods of the state, Socrates shows that Meletus is saying that spirits are the offspring of gods, and since no one believes in flutes playing without flute players, or in horses’ offspring without horses, Socrates could not believe in the …

What style of argument does Socrates use against Meletus charges against Socrates?

Socratic irony can be seen again in the argument to prove to Meletus that if Socrates had corrupted the youth it must have been done involuntarily and for that reason ought not to be punished. The reason given is that no one would voluntarily do harm to the people among whom he would have to live.

Does Socrates agree with Meletus?

Eventually, however, Socrates gets an answer from Meletus, who claims that the laws make the young good. Socrates does not accept this answer, insisting that he wants to know “the person whose first business it is to know the laws.” (24e).

What does Socrates say to defend himself against the charges of Meletus quizlet?

How does Socrates defend himself from the old charges? Socrates always says he does not know something and then asks someone. Socrates concluded that non of the politicians are right. They are not wise.

How does Socrates show Meletus to have contradicted himself in regard to Socrates belief in the gods?

Furthermore, Socrates points out that Meletus has involved himself in a self-contradiction: he accuses Socrates of introducing new and strange divinities and at the same time asserts that he is an atheist who does not believe in any god.

How does Socrates use the analogy of the horse breeders to cast doubt on Meletus concern for these matters?

How does socrates use the analogy of the horse breeders to cast doubt on Meletus’ concern for these matters? Socrates uses the horse breeder analogy to imply that it is impractical to assume that only one man corrupts an entire population of people. Meletus says that Socrates is corrupting the youth intentionally.

What is Socrates defense that he has not been corrupting the youth?

Specifically, the Apology of Socrates is a defence against the charges of “corrupting the youth” and “not believing in the gods in whom the city believes, but in other daimonia that are novel” to Athens (24b).

Why does Meletus contradict himself?

{ 4 } – Showing that Meletus contradicts himself. The contradiction is that in saying that Socrates does not believe in the gods at all (26c), Meletus is contradicting his official charge that Socrates believes in new divinities (26b). The “new divinities” refers to Socrates’ divine sign from god (See 31c).

What did Meletus say about Socrates in the apology?

Having made his defense against the first class of his accusers, Socrates proceeds to reply to the specific charges that are now being made against him. Meletus has stated that Socrates is a doer of evil in that he corrupts the youth, does not believe in the gods of the state, and has introduced new divinities of his own.

Why did Meletus raise charges against Socrates in the Odyssey?

Regarding the claim that he was against the state religion, Socrates defended himself by accusing Meletus of not doing adequate investigation. In fact, Meletus brought charges against Socrates mainly because of issues related to religion.

How did Socrates make Meletus look dim witted?

No record of Meletus’s speech survives. According to the partisan account of Plato in the Apology, Socrates–during his three-hour defense–entered into an exchange with Meletus and succeeded in making him appear rather dim-witted.

Is there any historical record of Meletus the Greek?

There is very little historical record concerning Meletus, other than what Socrates himself says in Plato ’s writings.